This is an email I sent on 15 July 2013 in support of Rose Lemberg’s report about harassment by FJ Bergmann at Wiscon 2012. It is posted publicly with Rose’s permission, in support of this post, which I’ve co-signed.
Dear Wiscon Safety,
With Rose Lemberg’s approval, I am writing a formal report of the incident of FJ Bergmann harassing Rose at Wiscon in 2012, which I witnessed. Rose is copied into this email.
I was at the Moment of Change launch reading that Rose Lemberg hosted, and I heard the poem that FJ Bergmann read. It was an offensive, anti-feminist poem in its own right, nasty about the woman at the core of the poem (surely a very 101-level failure and inappropriate for a feminist, intersectional reading). But as FJ Bergmann read it, I kept hearing things that made me think it was aimed at Rose: the references to Russia (where Rose is from, and Rose has talked about this publicly multiple times in the years before Wiscon 2012), to birds (which feature prominently in Rose’s work), to Siberia (where Rose has lived, although this is not as widely known, but this has also featured in some of Rose’s work). I know there are other details that other audience members picked up on (anti-Semitism, PhD references, accent mockery – all relevant to Rose, who is a Jewish academic with an accent).
It left me with the distinct impression that the poem had been aimed at Rose, down to its minute details, and the nastiness directed at the woman of the poem was thus directed at Rose.
It made me feel very uncomfortable, so after the reading I spoke to several other friends who had been present – and I found that we had *all* felt very uncomfortable and were sure that it had been aimed at Rose: an active attack on her.
I do not think it possible that this was a misunderstanding. It was too specifically targeted at Rose, too nasty and hurtful.
In the interests of disclosure, I was friends with Rose prior to that Wiscon, as were some of the other people I spoke to, but I do not think that coloured our interpretations at all. (I was thinking “Surely this poem isn’t aimed at Rose… surely…” but by the end of the poem I was sure it was, and I afterwards found that everyone I spoke to agreed.)
It was upsetting to witness, and I know it has been deeply upsetting to Rose and still is, and I offer my support to Rose in this situation.
All the best,
Alex Dally MacFarlane
Last Friday I posted at (Hugo Award-nominated fanzine) Pornokitsch with a Friday Five: five fascinating maps. Maps are the best! I love writing about maps!
Mentioned in my bio are a few map-related stories I’ll have out this year.
One is in Phantasm Japan, a Haikasoru anthology edited by Nick Mamatas and Masumi Washington, out in September. They recently announced the TOC, which includes my story “Inari Updates the Map of Rice Fields”. The title gives away the contents: Inari, maps, mapping of the world from “centre” to “edge”. At the “centre” is a rice map, which looks something like this 8th C CE example (the grid, annotated, with landscape details at its edges):
I read a couple of interesting articles from the free The History of Cartography when researching it late last year: Kazutaka Unno’s “Cartography in Japan” and Kazuhiko Miyajima’s “Japanese Celestial Cartography before the Meiji Period”. (It actually turned out to be relevant to my academic research, in that it provided useful knowledge of comparative mapping approaches elsewhere in the world.) I’m incredibly excited to be in Phantasm Japan. The TOC is a mixture of Japanese and non-Japanese writers, which has produced a different line-up to other anthologies. I look forward to reading it. I’m also excited to be working (in a small way) with Haikasoru, which is a fantastic imprint, publishing an ever-increasing body of Japanese SFF in English translation. If #WeNeedDiverseBooks crossed your twitter/tumblr/Facebook at the beginning of this month and you want to read more widely, head over to Haikasoru; the sheer range of what they publish ensures you’ll find at least one that interests you. There’s even a non-binary SF book!
Another story is in Upgraded, Neil Clarke’s cyborg anthology. “Coastline of the Stars” is about a missing artist of maps, Sermi Hu, whose work includes a tactile star map inspired by the tactile wooden maps of Ammassalik I mention in the Pornokitsch post. I want a tactile star map. (I want to write about Sermi Hu more, too.)
Then there’s Gigantic Worlds, which is out in the next couple of months; and Interfictions Online, which is a recent sale to the fall issue, which I’ll talk about later.
Last week my novelette “Women in Sandstone” was published in Beneath Ceaseless Skies. A general crosses a desert of living winds to outdo her world’s Alexander the Great. It opens:
“Your mouth is hanging open like a bell,” the South-East Wind said. “I wonder, if the wind blows between your teeth, will you clang or chime?”
The general tore her gaze from the temple’s walls. The tall wine-dark plume on her silver helmet bobbed and swayed in the North Wind | I blow through it and it is like the grass near a battlefield: heavy with the smells of burning and blood and bones | and then it tilted as she removed the helmet, revealing her hair — long and black with white running through it like embroidery, fastened in four thick braids — and the extent of her dark, scarred face. “I wish to honor your great temple,” she said.
Other favourite details include the Alexander references. Here’s a guide:
(1) Kandros is obviously Alexander. Where the real Alexander died in Babylon, after returning from India when his army mutinied and insisted on returning west, Kandros went alone to the desert of the winds. After Alexander (and Kandros) died, the lands conquered fell into generations of war between the Successors. Berenike was a common name for royal women among the Successors of Alexander.
(2) Berenike’s breastplate is embossed with “a woman, heroically nude, stabbing a lion that reared on its hind legs” because a) heroic nudity is an artistic convention for men in ancient Greek cultures, and I liked the idea of a woman using that convention, b) Achaemenid Persian kings (the dynasty Alexander defeated in Persia) liked to depict themselves stabbing lions on their hind legs, like so, just as Assyrian kings did before them. There’s a lot of inheritance of kingship motifs in the Near East, in architecture, textual traditions, etc, which Alexander’s textual traditions participated in (and Alexander himself!) so Berenike, as a Successor to Kandros, would adopt kingship motifs to demonstrate her (intended) kingship.
(3) Berenike’s shield is “embossed with a map of the world’s mountains” because mountains are an important motif in the way the world is described in textual traditions about Alexander, which draw (I argue) from Near Eastern traditions in which mountains are also important. Mountains are at the edges of the world, where heroes journey, heroic/legendary acts occur and “inhuman” peoples live. A conqueror like Berenike would embrace this motif in her own narratives — would want to reach every mountain range and outdo her predecessors’ deeds there. See, later: “…the high mountains where people with partridge bodies were rumored to live…” The people with partridge bodies are from the Cuthean Legend about Naram-Sin, a descendant of Sargon, a real and legendary king of Akkad.
(4) Berenike’s coins are described as having thick curls of hair over her forehead, though her hair’s straight. The famous coins of Alexander minted by Lysimachus depict Alexander with thick, curly hair, which it stands to reason a Successor like Berenike (especially one, like Berenike, who is noticeably mixed race) would emulate.
(5) Berenike’s mother was Central Asian: an Amazon, a tradition of warrior women inspired by the real warrior women of Central Asian societies. The Amazons were said to have sent a delegation to Alexander, at a different point in his invasion to when they meet him in this story. The sea of grass is the steppe.
(6) Šammuramat (Š = ‘Sh’) is the name of the real royal Assyrian woman who may have been the model for Semiramis, who Alexander is said to have outdone in crossing the Gedrosian desert. (Semiramis and Alexander are interesting: they’re both exemplars for each other.) It’s convenient for Berenike that she has a good story (that happens to be true) about herself in the desert of Šammuramat.
(7) This simile: “…like one of a pair of snakes leading her across the desert.” When Alexander went to the temple at Siwa (in Egypt) to consult Zeus Ammon, he became lost in the desert, upon which two snakes appeared to lead him to the temple. This is told by Arrian, who is considered our ‘sober’, ‘factual’ source for Alexander’s campaigns.
(8) Roshanak is the name of Alexander’s Bactrian wife. It’s not impossible that she would have had contacts among the nomadic peoples of the steppe. Her life after Kandros’ death is a lot better than her life after Alexander’s.
I think that’s all. If anyone wants to know more, do ask!
I had a lot of fun mixing ancient history into a world that’s very fictional, too, with winds that “blow the winged women of the Aĝir people into the snowstorms where they test their strength” and see “a palimpsest of women, mother under daughter, granddaughter like a scarf around them both”.
SF Signal had the announcement yesterday: the TOC and cover for The Mammoth Book of SF Stories by Women. Here it is, for those who missed it.
The anthology is scheduled for release in the UK and USA (and other territories where UK/USA books appear) late in the year.
I’m incredibly excited and proud.
Sofia Samatar — Girl Hours
Kristin Mandigma — Excerpt from a Letter by a Social-realist Aswang
Vandana Singh — Somadeva: A Sky River Sutra
Lucy Sussex — The Queen of Erewhon
Tori Truslow — Tomorrow Is Saint Valentine’s Day
Nnedi Okorafor — Spider the Artist
Karen Joy Fowler — The Science of Herself
Alice Sola Kim — The Other Graces
Elizabeth Bear & Sarah Monette — Boojum
Natalia Theodoridou — The Eleven Holy Numbers of the Mechanical Soul
Ursula K. Le Guin — Mountain Ways
Nalo Hopkinson — Tan–Tan and Dry Bone
Zen Cho — The Four Generations of Chang E
Élisabeth Vonarburg — Stay Thy Flight
Carrie Vaughn — Astrophilia
Hao Jingfang — Invisible Planets (translated by Ken Liu)
Nicole Kornher–Stace — On the Leitmotif of the Trickster Constellation in Northern Hemispheric Star Charts, Post-Apocalypse
Shira Lipkin — Valentines
Rochita Loenen-Ruiz — Dancing in the Shadow of the Once
Nancy Kress — Ej–Es
E. Lily Yu — The Cartographer Wasps and the Anarchist Bees
Toiya Kristen Finley — The Death of Sugar Daddy
Kameron Hurley — Enyo–Enyo
Genevieve Valentine — Semiramis
Aliette de Bodard — Immersion
Greer Gilman — Down the Wall
Karin Tidbeck — Sing
Nisi Shawl — Good Boy
Thoraiya Dyer — The Second Card of the Major Arcana
Ekaterina Sedia — A Short Encyclopedia of Lunar Seas
Benjanun Sriduangkaew — Vector
Angélica Gorodischer — Concerning the Unchecked Growth of Cities (translated by Ursula K. Le Guin)
Catherynne M. Valente — The Radiant Car Thy Sparrows Drew
My poem “Her Sun-patterned Eye” is in Strange Horizons!
It belongs to a wider series of poems I’m writing about ancient/prehistoric archaeological finds, which includes “Bowl” and “Thousands of Years Ago, I Made This String Skirt” in Stone Telling and “Sister” in Through the Gate. I’m fascinated by people very distant in time, by people whose stories are rarely told and by how the past is written about: the metaphor of a palimpsest is useful here, the past visible between the lines of the future, and I’d like what’s visible to be a truer look at the past than what we get in most popular discourse.
When I read about the bones of a c.2900 BCE woman found at Shahr-e Sukhteh, 6 feet tall with a prosthetic eye covered in gold, carved with a sun-pattern, I wanted to write about her. What an eye! What a story she must have had! One artist on tumblr drew her, which I love. Here she is, as we know her:
Bones. Is writing for a find of bones and grave goods truly history, or historiography? I started writing a narrative for her, a world she saw through her gilt eye. I stopped. The problem of filling in the gaps, of fictionalising, is one that historians (especially of the ancient world) face, and though I can embrace writing story in fiction or poetry, I apparently can’t do it for long without stopping to question it. “Her Sun-patterned Eye” is me questioning it: the opening up of possibility, the narrowing down again to truth, to bones. Remarkable bones, a surely remarkable woman. I hope this poem means more people are aware of her.
Last night I went to the launch of issue 2 of Verse Kraken, a zine edited by Claire Trévien and Tori Truslow. The new issue will be online soon; at the launch, the contributors present read their work – a really enjoyable mix of poetic, experimental pieces – and the editors sold out the super limited print edition. It’s stuck into old copies of The Handbook of the British Astronomical Association, in places a palimpsestical collage: my poem, “Three Palimpsests on Ganymede”, is on a page called Lunar Occulations. Look:
Two more glimpses: Alex Boyd’s “St Kilda (The False Land)” and the back, listing items published in earlier editions of the handbook, including “Pleiades, The” and “Stars, The Brightests and Nearest”.
My favourite piece at the launch was Hel Gurney’s “The Book Remembers”, an audio palimpsest of Anglo-Saxon voice and women’s stories. I also loved James Coghill’s “Sunt Stellae XIII: Three Surrealist Translations”. Very short pieces lend themselves well to a reading event: there’s plenty of variety, and ample time between and after the readings to actually talk to people. (I’m not such a fan of reading events that are just the readings.)
An excellent, tentacular night!
2014 so far: BUSY BUSY BUSY.
Earlier this month, PodCastle published the podcast of my story “Feed Me the Bones of Our Saints”, read by Eleiece Kraweic. It’s free to listen. Foxes and women without men waging war for revenge and survival.
My Post-Binary Gender in SF column on Tor.com continues. The latest post is called Poetry’s Potential for Voice, in which I talk about the potency I love in poetry and its potential for post-binary voices. I take a closer look at poems by Bogi Takács, Natalia Theodoridou, Tori Truslow and Shweta Narayan.
I’ve got a great roundtable about languages and gender in the works for the column, a conversation with an expert on Iain M. Banks’ Culture novels (once I’ve done more reading), as well as more posts about specific texts. Melissa Scott’s Shadow Man is up next.
I’m in a different roundtable today: “Inclusive Reviewing: A Discussion” in Strange Horizons. The roundtable includes Samuel R. Delany, L. Timmel Duchamp, Fabio Fernandes, Andrea Hairston, Sofia Samatar, Aishwarya Subramanian and me, responding to Nisi Shawl’s article “Reviewing the Other” in the same issue. I speak briefly about reviewers and lack of understanding of non-binary gender.
Lastly, co-editor Claire Trévien posted a sneak-preview of the limited edition print versions of Verse Kraken‘s next issue, which will also be published online and will include my poem “Three Palimpsests on Ganymede”. You can read a bit of it in the bottom-left part of the sneak-preview. The full TOC of issue 2 is on their blog. It will be launched on 3 April at the Dogstar in Brixton, London. Event info on FB!
I’m so pleased to say that my genderqueer science fiction story “Found”, originally published in Clarkesworld‘s August 2013 issue, will be reprinted in The Year’s Best Science Fiction & Fantasy edited by Rich Horton. The list of contents was announced at SF Signal, but I’m reproducing it here because I think it’s great: Maureen McHugh, Lavie Tidhar, Yoon Ha Lee, Benjanun Sriduangkaew, Yukimi Ogawa, CSE Cooney, Eleanor Arnason, Geoff Ryman, Erik Amundsen and many more writers whose work I admire and enjoy. I look forward to reading a contributor copy. The anthology is scheduled for June 2014.
“Social Services” by Madeline Ash (An Aura of Familiarity)
“Out in the Dark” by Linda Nagata (Analog)
“The End of the World as We Know It, and We Feel Fine” by Harry Turtledove (Analog)
“The Oracle” by Lavie Tidhar (Analog)
“Call Girl” by Tang Fei (Apex)
“Ilse, Who Saw Clearly” by E. Lily Yu (Apex)
“They Shall Salt the Earth With Seeds of Glass” by Alaya Dawn Johnson (Asimov’s)
“The Wildfires of Antarctica” by Alan De Niro (Asimov’s)
“The Discovered Country” by Ian R. MacLeod (Asimov’s)
“A Stranger from a Foreign Ship” by Tom Purdom (Asimov’s)
“On the Origin of Song” by Naim Kabir (Beneath Ceaseless Skies)
“Effigy Nights” by Yoon Ha Lee (Clarkesworld)
“Soulcatcher” by James Patrick Kelly (Clarkesworld)
“Found” by Alex Dally MacFarlane (Clarkesworld)
“The Bees Her Heart, the Hive Her Belly” by Benjanun Sriduangkaew (Clockwork Phoenix 4)
“Loss, With Chalk Diagrams” by E. Lily Yu (Eclipse Online)
“A Brief History of the Trans-Pacific Tunnel” by Ken Liu (F&SF)
“Kormak the Lucky” by Eleanor Arnason (F&SF)
“Grizzled Veterans of Many and Much” by Robert Reed (F&SF)
“Rosary and Goldenstar” by Geoff Ryman (F&SF)
“The Dragons of Merebarton” by K.J. Parker (Fearsome Journeys)
“Martyr’s Gem” by C. S. E. Cooney (Giganotosaurus)
“Such & Such Said to So & So” by Maria Dahvana Headley (Glitter & Mayhem)
“Killing Curses, a Caught-Heart Quest” by Krista Hoeppner Leahy (Lady Churchill’s Rosebud Wristlet)
“A Fine Show on the Abyssal Plain” by Karin Tidbeck (Lightspeed)
“Paranormal Romance” by Christopher Barzak (Lightspeed)
“The Dead Sea-Bottom Scrolls” by Howard Waldrop (Old Mars)
“Blanchefleur” by Theodora Goss (Once Upon a Time)
“The Memory Book” by Maureen McHugh (Queen Victoria’s Book of Spells)
“Live Arcade” by Erik Amundsen (Strange Horizons)
“Town’s End” by Yukimi Ogawa (Strange Horizons)
“A Window or a Small Box” by Jedediah Berry (Tor.com)
“Trafalgar and Josefina” by Angelica Gorodischer (Trafalgar)
“Firebrand” by Peter Watts (Twelve Tomorrows)
“Game of Chance” by Carrie Vaughn (Unfettered)
“Found” will also be reprinted in How to Live on Other Planets: A Handbook for Aspiring Aliens edited by Joanne Merriam, scheduled for 2015. It’s an anthology about the immigrant experience in science fiction. The list of contents was announced on the publisher’s website, but I want to share it as well because it looks great: Rose Lemberg, Sonya Taaffe, Bogi Takács, Nisi Shawl, Indrapramit Das, Zen Cho and many other excellent authors whose work I’m delighted to have mine alongside. Again, the contributor copy is going to be a treat.
Dean Francis Alfar, “Ohkti”
Celia Lisset Alvarez, “Malibu Barbie Moves to Mars”
R.J. Astruc, “A Believer’s Guide to Azagarth”
Lisa Bao, “like father, like daughter”
Pinckney Benedict, “Zog-19: A Scientific Romance”
Lisa Bolekaja, “The Saltwater African”
Mary Buchinger, “Transplanted”
Zen Cho, “The Four Generations of Chang E”
Abbey Mei Otis, “Blood, Blood”
Tina Connolly, “Turning the Apples”
Indrapramit Das, “muo-ka’s Child”
Tom Doyle, “The Floating Otherworld”
Peg Duthie, “With Light-Years Come Heaviness”
Thomas Greene, “Zero Bar”
Benjamin S. Grossberg, “The Space Traveler’s Husband,” “The Space Traveler and the Promised Planet” and “The Space Traveler and Boston”
Minal Hajratwala, “The Unicorn at the Racetrack”
Julie Bloss Kelsey, “tongue lashing” and “the itch of new skin”
Rose Lemberg, “The Three Immigrations”
Ken Liu, “Ghost Days”
Alex Dally MacFarlane, “Found”
Anil Menon, “Into The Night”
Joanne Merriam, “Little Ambushes”
Mary Anne Mohanraj, “Jump Space”
Daniel José Older, “Phantom Overload”
Sarah Pinsker, “The Low Hum of Her”
Elyss G. Punsalan, “Ashland”
Benjamin Rosenbaum, “The Guy Who Worked For Money”
Erica L. Satifka, “Sea Changes”
Nisi Shawl, “In Colors Everywhere”
Marge Simon, “South”
Sonya Taaffe, “Di Vayse Pave”
Bogi Takács, “The Tiny English-Hungarian Phrasebook For Visiting Extraterrestrials”
Bryan Thao Worra, “Dead End In December” and “The Deep Ones”
Deborah Walker, “Speed of Love”
Nick Wood, “Azania”
A new zine is live: Lackington’s! Their inaugural issue includes writing by Rose Lemberg, Amal El-Mohtar, Erik Amundsen, Helen Marshall, Christine Miscione, Kate Heartfield — and a reprint of my story “An Orange Tree Framed Your Body”. It’s about clones, depression and oranges, and here’s the opening:
the boy and the road talk youth
I’m sitting on the side of a dusty road, thinking of oranges. Thinking of my father and of death—his and mine. The Emperor’s assemblage of cars comes past, shining and identical, but today I do not care about him and the fighting for the city.
I am surprised—every hour today, this moment of not understanding—that I have reached this birthday.
The story originally appeared in the much-missed print zine Sybil’s Garage 7 in 2010, edited by Matthew Kressel. Big thanks to Matt for originally publishing the story, and to Ranylt Richildis of Lackington’s for presenting it to a new audience.
In other good writing news, my story “Selin That Has Grown In The Desert”, published in Steam-Powered 2: More Lesbian Steampunk Stories in 2011, edited by JoSelle Vanderhooft, will be reprinted in Sean Wallace’s The Mammoth Book of Steampunk Adventures, forthcoming later this year. The TOC is here. It looks pretty great.
I’ll also have a new flash-length story, “The (De)Composition of Evidence”, in Noir edited by Ian Whates, part of a double anthology (paired with La Femme) to be released by Newcon Press at Eastercon this spring. It gave me an opportunity to play with plunderverse and a dead person’s skin.
I recently launched a column at Tor.com about post-binary gender. So far the introduction has gone live. Go read, if that’s your sort of thing! I hope to do awesome things with this column: talking about books/stories I’ve read, both recently published and older, talking to other writers and readers about the subject, broadening my own horizons while (hopefully) broadening other people’s too.
I opened the introduction by saying: “I want an end to the default of binary gender in science fiction stories.”
I really truly do! I’m not being hyperbolic to kickstart discussion. I really want an end to the default of binary gender, which apparently I need to translate for some people: I want there to be no default does not mean I want there to be no binary-gendered people in science fiction. There are many binary-gendered people in the world! This will no doubt continue to be the case.
I also said: “People who do not fit comfortably into the gender binary exist in our present, have existed in our past, and will exist in our futures. So too do people who are binary-gendered but are often ignored, such as trans* people who identify as binary-gendered. I am not interested in discussions about the existence of these gender identities: we might as well discuss the existence of women or men. Gender complexity exists. SF that presents a rigid, unquestioned gender binary is false and absurd.”
This is not an opinion. This is a fact. Non-binary people exist. Not including non-binary people is false. Barely including non-binary people is false. No, there isn’t a magic number of non-binary that you need to include (haven’t we already discussed how no one is calling for quotas when they call for diversity?) but there does need to be a feeling, when I read about a future, that it includes people of all genders, even if the individual story is focused on a cis man, or a cis woman. Needless to say, sometimes non-binary people should be the focus. But not always!
I didn’t think this was an especially confrontational or controversial demand, but hey! The internet is here to prove me wrong.
Larry Correia wrote a long post about how I’m wrong! damnit, so wrong! and only in my twenties! and stuff like that, which Jim C Hines took apart so you don’t have to, for which I am grateful. Jim’s post nicely shows how Larry circles around the same strawmen while calling himself a fascist for misgendering me. Thanks, Jim!
Then Jim got comments.
NEVER READ THE COMMENTS! you shout. TOO LATE! I lament. Actually, the comments are really interesting, because there’s this regularly raised idea of being “civil” or “polite” or “reasonable”. Some commenters complain that people’s comments got unfairly deleted from my Tor.com post despite being reasonable, which amuses me because I know one comment got deleted for saying that non-binary people are just insane, so BULLSHIT. Indeed, a Tor.com moderator stepped in to explain why comments got deleted. But here’s another thing: let’s take a look at the comments Jim got.
EXHIBIT 1: “You see, when you are struggling to survive these are lesser concerns. Nowadays, at least in Europe, the US, Canada, etc., people have the leisure to worry about whether they were born with the right sex organs, etc. Or whether people can marry their sofa.” quoth Mike Murley
1. Equating trans* and non-binary gender rights to marrying a sofa is transphobic and cissexist.
2. Equating equal marriage to marrying a sofa is homophobic.
3. Non-binary and trans* people existed throughout history.
4. Non-binary and trans* people exist in the contemporary “third world”. Here’s an example: Thailand is the leading country for SRS (re-assignment surgery) and has people of non-binary gender (kathoey). The idea that only in the West do people have the “leisure” to be trans*/non-binary is racist, Western-centric bullshit.
5. Piss off.
EXHIBIT 2: “First, yes, there are people out there that list their “gender/sex” however the heck you want to say it as other than male/female. Whoopdeedoo. Basic biology is… for evolved life forms on planet earth, there is male and female. There is not computersexual, there is not barcoloungersexual, there is not magazinesexual. There are just two.” quoth Rick
1. I’m so glad you’re our biology teacher today! What with your utter ignorance about biological sex. Read up on intersex people, then on genital and chromosomal differentiation more widely. The biological binary is bullshit.
2. Equating real genders and biological sexes to computers, barcoloungers(?) and magazines is gross.
3. Piss off.
EXHIBIT 3: “There are, in Terran-based biology, two sexes (usually misidentified as “genders” – nouns have genders, people are one of two sexes). Male and female. This is reality. There are a significant number of human-based sexual preferences and gender identifications, which have become increasingly more apparent due to a larger number of humans having their basic needs met and having the leisure time to concern themselves with these (in first world societies, if we use the out-dated World Bank definition).” quoth Mike Murley, again
1. What is it with Terran-based cis people and the faulty biology lessons?
2. See above, re: racism.
2. Piss off.
EXHIBIT 4: “The vast majority of people want the characters to be just men and women. Sure every now and then its good to expand your horizons but that doesn’t require and end to the defaults. Its like getting rid of the english default on your computer. Sure every now and then a customer wants something like klingon or farsi but most people just want to play video games and surf the web and so the default english works for them. Do you really think the majority of twilight fans want Bella to secretly be a dude dressed as a girl?” quoth Demetrias
1. Saying that real people’s lived existence, ie: the existence of non-binary people, is an exercise to “expand your horizons” is cissexist.
2. Not everyone’s keyboard has English default. Did you know that some keyboards have Farsi as a default? Or one of several language settings? Klingon is not a language beyond Star Trek. Equating it with Farsi is racist.
3. Baffling transphobia seals the deal, I guess?
4. Piss off.
That’s enough of that.
Tell me more about how cissexism, transphobia and racism are “civil” and “reasonable” and “not insulting”. How the fuck is this shit okay to say? How the fuck can you hide behind words like “reasonable” because you didn’t, what, call me a bitch or threaten to harm me while you were spewing your hateful, bigoted words all over Jim’s comments section? The idea that you are being civil in comments because you’re not being aggressive or using slurs or threatening violence is a fascinating one. It is not reasonable to be bigoted. It is not civil. It is not “not insulting” to say that non-binary and trans* people don’t exist in non-Western countries and that there are only two sexes and lol r u computersexual.
Closing comments on this one. Don’t actually tell me more about your bigotry. Piss off.
"...the 33 stories that MacFarlane has gathered for this volume dazzle with the virtuosity of their contributors’ talents."
- Publishers Weekly: STARRED REVIEW
"Works from around the world, some in translation, provide an invaluable snapshot of this moment in the genre as well as some tremendously enjoyable reading."
- Publishers Weekly: Best Books of 2014
"The stories range widely in scope and form — from prose poems to metafiction — to capture a dynamic, forward-thinking genre that plays with history, myth and science."
- The Washington Post: Think science fiction is dominated by men? Think again.
"...ground-breaking and superbly conceived..."
- Nina Allan: Strange Horizons: 2014 In Review
Aliens: Recent Encounters
"...this [anthology] blew us away more than any other. Mostly because of the sheer volume of greatness contained in these 32 stories... These are classic stories of alien encounters, from some of the best science fiction writers working today."
- io9.com Best Books of 2013